Academics in Support of Professor Carole S. Vance
To: Lee C. Bollinger, President
Seth Low Professor of the University
Columbia University
John H. Coatsworth, Provost
Professor of International and Public Affairs Professor of History
Columbia University
Dear President Bollinger and Provost Coatsworth,
We are writing as colleagues of Dr. Carole S. Vance to express our shock and dismay regarding the letter of “non-renewal” that Dr. Vance received, terminating her position as of June 30, 2014 – without cause and without compensation. After more than 27 years of exemplary service to Columbia, this decision strikes us as unethical and shortsighted.
On January 23, Provost Coatsworth received a letter from more than 30 prominent scholars protesting this action and requesting his intervention. We are disappointed that there has been no response to that letter.
We will not detail Dr. Vance’s formidable contributions, which were amply documented in the Scholars’ Letter previously delivered to you, as well as in petitions from her current and former students and post-docs. Instead, we confine this petition to these key points:
• Dr. Carole Vance is an internationally-respected, path-breaking medical anthropologist.
• Dr. Vance has been crucial in shaping multiple academic fields for three decades — gender and sexuality studies, medical anthropology, public health, and human rights.
• Dr. Vance has taken serious intellectual and political risks in presenting scholarship that has always been ahead of its time, and that has engaged highly-charged issues such as pornography, American domestic policies on sexuality and freedom of speech, conceptual biases in epidemiological studies of HIV/AIDS, and more.
• For more than a decade, Dr. Vance has been a global thought leader on human trafficking, challenging scholars and activists to find ways to address sexual violence and exploitation without inadvertently re-energizing sexual ideologies such as female sexual purity which strengthen the sexual strictures on socially marginalized groups.
• Dr. Vance’s longstanding Program for the Study of Sexuality, Gender, Health, and Human Rights inaugurated a new field of study at the same time that it galvanized an interdisciplinary and international network. By bringing together scholars from diverse academic fields (law, history, anthropology, women’s and gender studies, art history, literature and cultural studies), public health practitioners, activists and lawyers working in or directing non-governmental organizations, no one has done more to foster thoughtful relations among those working on sexuality and on international human rights.
• Carole Vance is beloved as a teacher, having taught some 100 courses and over 1,300 students in the Department of Sociomedical Sciences at Columbia University.
• Columbia University has benefitted immeasurably from Dr. Vance’s meticulous and tireless work, judging from the fact that she has been awarded many of the highest faculty honors at Columbia University: the 1999 Outstanding Teacher Award at the Mailman School of Public Health, the 2005 Tannenbaum-Warner Award for exceptional service to the University Seminars, and the 2007- 2008 Faculty Mentoring Award from the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences.
• In Columbia’s Department of Sociomedical Sciences, Dr. Vance has done far more than her share of student mentoring, running the methods exam committee for many years, and directing the Sexuality Studies track within the M.P.H. program.
• Dr. Vance is a rare academic who has consistently reached beyond the university to include legal, clinical, and public health practitioners as well as advocates and activists in focused and sustained conversations about how to advance justice and human freedoms.
• From extensive international work and a strong commitment to international students, Dr. Vance enjoys the wide respect of scholars, practitioners, and activists, and is known for her brilliant and respectful engagements with colleagues all around the globe.
We have learned that the decision to terminate Dr. Vance has been framed as a budgetary issue, and is part of a larger move requiring non-tenured faculty to raise the majority of their salaries from external grants. This cynical decision sends two key messages to scholars at Columbia and elsewhere. First, because teaching and mentoring do not bring in grant money, faculty who prioritize students will be actively punished for that. Students do not matter. Second, brilliant, transformative scholarship is unimportant in the corporate university.
As scholars across an enormous array of fields, we have learned from, taught, and drawn fresh inspiration from Carole Vance’s work over and over again. We urge you to recognize and reward—rather than punish—this great scholar for the risks she has taken. Columbia has drawn ample benefit from Carole Vance’s work over the decades, both directly in her service to the University and also by the stature that she brings to the institution. We urge you to do the right thing and reinstate her contract.
Respectfully signed by (List in progress):
[NOTE: To sign the petition, enter your name and title in the ‘name’ field, and your academic affiliation and any additional comments in the ‘comment’ field. Titles and affiliations will be noted as “for identification purposes only.”]
Elazar Barkan
Professor of International and Public Affairs
Director, Human Rights Concentration, School of International and Public Affairs
Director, Columbia University Institute for the Study of Human Rights
Lee Anne Bell
Professor and Barbara Silver Horowitz Director of Education
Barnard College
Jonathan Beller
Professor
Humanities and Media Studies
Graduate Program in Media Studies
Pratt Institute
Judith Butler
Tam Mellon Visiting Professor in the Humanities
Columbia University
Mary Ann Case Arnold I. Shure Professor of Law
University of Chicago Law School
Yvette Christiansë
Professor, Africana Studies & English Literature
Chair, Barnard International and Global Sub-Committee
Barnard College
Christina Crosby
Professor of English and Feminist, Gender, and Sexuality Studies
Wesleyan University
Arlene Davila
Professor of Anthropology and Social and Cultural Analysis
New York University
Ellen DuBois
Professor of History and Gender Studies
UCLA
Alice Echols
Barbra Streisand Professor in Contemporary Gender Studies and
Professor of English and History
Chair, Gender Studies & Director, The Center for Feminist Research
University of Southern California
Michelle Fine
Distinguished Professor of Critical Psychology
The Graduate Center at CUNY
Kate Flint
Provost Professor of English and Art History
Chair: Department of Art History
University of Southern California
Jean Franco
Professor Emeritus English/Comparative Literature
Columbia University
Elizabeth Freeman
Professor of English and Editor of GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies
University of California, Davis
Hillevi Ganetz
Professor, Director
Dept. of Ethnology, History of Religions and Gender Studies
Stockholm University
Larry P. Gross
Vice Dean; School of Communication Director and Professor
Annenberg School of Journalism
University of Southern California
Lori Gruen
Professor, Philosophy, FGSS, and ENVS
Coordinator, Wesleyan Animal Studies
Wesleyan University
Kim F. Hall
Lucyle Hook Chair
Professor of Africana Studies and English
Barnard College
Holly Hughes
Professor, School of Art & Design
Professor, Department of Theatre and Drama
University of Michigan
Lynn Hunt
Distinguished Research Professor
UCLA
Janet Jakobsen
Ann Whitney Olin Professor of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies
Director of the Barnard Center for Research on Women
Barnard College
Lynne Joyrich
Professor, Department of Modern Culture and Media
Brown University
Ellen Lewin
Professor of Anthropology
University of Iowa
Nicola Mai
Professor of Sociology and Migration Studies
London Metropolitan University and Aix-Marseille University
Emily Martin Department of Anthropology Director, Institute for the History of Production of Knowledge New York University
Randy Martin
Professor and Chair
Department of Art and Public Policy
Tisch School of the Arts
New York University
Kathleen A. McHugh
Director, Center for the Study of Women
Professor, Department of English
Program in Cinema and Media Studies
UCLA
Sally Engle Merry
Silver Professor
Department of Anthropology
New York University
Ilan H. Meyer, Ph.D.
Senior Scholar for Public Policy
Williams Institute for Sexual Orientation Law and Public Policy
UCLA School of Law
Kristina Milnor
Professor and Chair
Department of Classics and Ancient Studies
Barnard College
Dr Anne Mulhall
Director, Centre for Gender, Culture and Identities
University College Dublin, Ireland
Dianne Otto
Professor and Francine V McNiff Chair in Human Rights Law
Melbourne Law School,
The University of Melbourne
Esther Newton
Professor of Anthropology
University of Michigan
Ann Pellegrini
Director, Center for the Study of Gender and Sexuality
Professor of Performance Studies & Religious Studies
New York University
Rosalind Petchesky
Distinguished Professor Emerita
Hunter College & The Graduate Center, CUNY
Sheila Rowbotham
Professor (ret.) and Honorary Fellow, Manchester University
Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts (F.R.S.A.)
Susan Riemer Sacks
Adjunct Professor of Psychology
Emerita Professor of Education
Barnard College
Bambi B. Schieffelin
Collegiate Professor
Professor, Anthropology
New York University
Nayan Shah
Professor and Chair of the Department of American Studies of Ethnicity
University of Southern California
Sally Sheldon
Professor, Kent Law School
Eliot College
University of Kent
Alisa Solomon
Professor, Graduate School of Journalism
Columbia University
Arlene Stein
Professor of Sociology
Rutgers University
Neferti X. M. Tadiar
Professor and Chair
Dept. of Women’s, Gender & Sexuality Studies
Barnard College, Columbia University
Miriam Ticktin
Associate Professor of Anthropology
The New School for Social Research
Deborah L. Tolman
Professor of Social Welfare and Psychology
Silberman School of Social Work at Hunter College
María Elena Torre, Phd
Director, The Public Science Project
Faculty, Critical Social Psychology
The Graduate Center of the City University of New York
Prof. dr. Mieke Verloo
Professor of Comparative Politics and Inequality Issues
Radboud University Nijmegen (the Netherlands)
Laura Wexler
Professor of American Studies
Professor of Women’s, Gender & Sexuality Studies
Director, The Photographic Memory Workshop
Yale University
Barbara Winslow
Professor
Secondary Education Department
Women’s and Gender Studies Program
Brooklyn College
Rebecca Jordan-Young
Tow Associate Professor of Women’s, Gender & Sexuality Studies
Barnard College
Todd Shepard
Associate Professor of History
The Johns Hopkins University
David Valentine
Associate Professor of Anthropology
University of Minnesota
Joan Nestle
Co-founder of the Lesbian Herstory Archives
Honorary Fellow, University of Melbourne, Australia
Charlotte M. Canning
Frank C. Erwin, Jr. Centennial Professor in Drama
Senior Editor, Theatre Research International
Director, Oscar G. Brockett Center for Theatre History and Criticism
Head, Performance as Public Practice MA/MFA/PhD programs
Department of Theatre and Dance
University of Texas at Austin
Gayatri Reddy
Associate Professor of Gender and Women’s Studies & Anthropology
University of Illinois at Chicago
Elizabeth Bernstein
Associate Professor of Sociology and
Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies
Barnard College
Emanuela Bianchi
Assistant Professor
Department of Comparative Literature
New York University
Evelyn Blackwood
Professor of Anthropology
Purdue University
Christa Craven
Chair of Women’s, Gender & Sexuality Studies
The College of Wooster
Margaret Wiener
Associate Professor of Anthropology
UNC Chapel Hill
Jigna Desai
Associate Professor and Chair of Gender, Women’s and Sexuality Studies
University of Minnesota
Margot Weiss
Associate Professor of American Studies and Anthropology
Wesleyan University
Kale Bantigue Fajardo
Associate Professor of American Studies and Asian American Studies
University of Minnesota
Rudolf Gaudio
Associate Professor of Anthropology
Purchase College, SUNY
Bonnie S. Anderson
Professor Emerita of History
Brooklyn College and the Graduate Center, CUNY
Paisley Currah
Professor of Political Science
Brooklyn College and The Graduate Center
City University of New York
Lisa Jean Moore
Professor of Sociology and Gender Studies
Juanita and Joseph Leff Distinguished Professor
Purchase College, State University of New York
Deborah Elliston
Assistant Professor of Anthropology and of Women’s Studies
Binghamton University
Kevin Murphy
Associate Professor of History
University of Minnesota
Katherine Frank
Scholar in Residence , Department of Sociology
American University
Jennifer Tucker
Associate Professor, Department of History and Science in Society Program
Wesleyan University
Dr Amade M’charek
Associate professor at the Department of Anthropology
University of Amsterdam (Netherlands)
Cynthia Kraus
Maître d’enseignement et de recherche
Institut des sciences sociales
Faculté des sciences sociales et politiques
Université de Lausanne (Switzerland)
Ashwini Tambe
Associate Professor, Dept. of Women’s Studies, University of Maryland-College Park
Affiliate faculty, Dept. of History and Asian American Studies Program
Editorial Director, Feminist Studies
Rianne Mahon
Professor and CIGI Chair
Balsillie School of International Affairs and Political Science
Wilfrid Laurier University
Joseph Lowndes
Associate Professor of Political Science
University of Oregon
Ângela Maria Carneiro Araújo
Full Professor, Department of Political Science
State University of Campinas (UNOCAMP) Brazil
Judith Frank
Professor of English and Elizabeth W. Bruss Reader
English Department Director of Studies
Amherst College
Rosemary Hunter AcSS
Professor, Kent Law School
University of Kent
Jennifer Gaboury
Associate Director, Women and Gender Studies Program
Hunter College, CUNY
Sarah E. Chinn
Professor of English
Hunter College, CUNY
C.J. Pascoe
Assistant Professor
Department of Sociology
University of Oregon
Chair, Sex & Gender Section of the American Sociological Association
J. Keith Vincent
Associate Professor of Japanese, Comparative Literature, and Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies
Boston University
Carla A. Pfeffer, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Sociology
Purdue University North Central
Laurel Westbrook
Assistant Professor
Department of Sociology
Grand Valley State University
Dr. Kate Drabinski
Gender and Women’s Studies Lecturer
University of Maryland, Baltimore County
Leslie Salzinger, Associate Professor
Gender and Women’s Studies
University of California, Berkeley
Jessica Fields
Associate Professor of Sociology
Graduate Studies Coordinator in Sexuality Studies
San Francisco State University
Dr. Kate Bedford
Reader in Law
Kent Law School
University of Kent
Jeffrey Escoffier
Director, Health Media & Digital Communications, NYC Dept of Health and Mental Hygiene
Adjunct Instructor, Sociology, Barnard College
Caroline Arnold
Assistant Professor of Political Science
Brooklyn College-CUNY
Portia Seddon
Adjunct Lecturer, Women & Gender Studies
Hunter College, CUNY
Laurie E. Naranch, Ph.D.
Associate Professor
Political Science Department
Director, Women’s Studies Minor
Siena College (London)
Rupal Oza
Director, The Women and Gender Studies Program
Hunter College, CUNY
Linda Martín Alcoff
Professor of Philosophy
Hunter College
CUNY Graduate Center
Matt Brim
Assistant Professor of Queer Studies
Department of English
College of Staten Island, CUNY
Co-editor, WSQ
The Feminist Press, CUNY
Ann Braithwaite, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, Coordinator
Diversity and Social Justice Studies (formerly Women’s Studies)
University of Prince Edward Island
Louis van den Hengel, PhD
Assistant Professor
Department of Literature and Art / Centre for Gender and Diversity
Maastricht University (The Netherlands)
Ritty Lukose
Associate Professor of Anthropology and South Asian Studies
Affiliated Faculty, Gender and Sexuality Studies
The Gallatin School of Individualized Study
New York University
Kyla Bender-Baird
Ph.D. Student, Sociology, CUNY Graduate Center
Graduate Teaching Fellow, Sociology, City College of New York
Adjunct Instructor, Women’s Studies, Brooklyn College
Brenda Roche, PhD
Director of Research
Wellesley Institute (Toronto)
Dr. Julie Passanante Elman
Assistant Professor of Women’s and Gender Studies
University of Missouri, Columbia
Katherine De Lorenzo
Women and Gender Studies Program
Hunter College, CUNY
Marc Siegel
Asst. Professor, Film Studies
Goethe University, Frankfurt, Germany
Dawne Moon
Assistant Professor of Sociology
Marquette University
Kimberly Kay Hoang, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Sociology
Boston College
Sandra Moog
Lecturer in Management and Sustainability
Essex Business School, University of Essex (UK)
Sameena A. Mulla
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Department of Social and Cultural Sciences
Marquette University
Brian Connolly
Assistant Professor of History
University of South Florida
Geertje Mak
Assistant Professor of History and Gender Studies
Radboud University, Nijmegen (The Netherlands)
Sandra Eder, PhD
Institute and Museum for the History of Medicine
University of Zurich
Dominique Vinck
Professeur ordinaire
Faculté de Sciences Sociales et Politiques
Institut des Sciences Sociales
Université de Lausanne (Switzerland)
Cristina Reyes Iborra
Sociology-Anthropology Gender and Development Studies
Université Paris 7 – Diderot
Deborah L. Little
Associate Professor, Dept of Anthropology and Sociology
Adelphi University
Sara McClelland, Ph.D.
Asst. Professor, Women’s Studies & Psychology
University of Michigan
Barbara A. Barnes
Gender & Women’s Studies
UC Berkeley
Christina Hanhardt
Associate Professor of American Studies
University of Maryland, College Park
Heather Levi
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Temple University
Elise Chenier
Associate Professor of History
Simon Fraser University
Don Romesburg
Associate Professor
Queer Studies Minor Advisor
Women’s and Gender Studies Department
Sonoma State University
Jessica R. Cattelino
Associate Professor of Anthropology
University of California, Los Angeles
Daniel Skinner, Ph.D
Assistant Professor of Health Policy
Department of Social Medicine
Ohio University, Heritage College of Osteopathic Medicine
Caroline Yezer
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
College of the Holy Cross, Worcester MA
Minette Church
Associate Professor of Anthropology
University of Colorado, Colorado Springs
Kimbra Smith
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
University of Colorado, Colorado Springs
Professor B Scherer, PhD
Chair in Comparative Religion, Gender and Sexuality
Canterbury Christ Church University
Vasuki Nesiah
Assoc. Prof. of Practice
The Gallatin School, NYU
Greta LaFleur
Assistant Professor of American Studies
Yale University
Dr Carolyn D’Cruz
Senior Lecturer, Program Convenor
Gender, Sexuality and Diversity Studies
School of Social Sciences
La Trobe University (Victoria, Australia)
Cindi Katz
Professor and Executive Officer
Earth and Environmental Sciences Program
CUNY Graduate Center
Dr Red Chan
Assistant Professor, Dept. of Translation
Lingnan University, Hong Kong
Alvaro Jarrin
Visiting Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Union College
Kerwin Kaye
Department of Sociology
SUNY Collage at Old Westbury
Marylène Lieber
Associate Professeur, Institute for Gender Studies and Department of Sociology University of Geneva (Switzerland)
Dr Melinda Chateauvert
Fellow, Center for Africana Studies
University of Pennsylvania
Benjamin Balthaser
Assistant Professor of English
Indiana University, South Bend
Teresa Kuan
Assistant Professor
Department of Anthropology
Chinese University of Hong Kong
Judith Owens
Assoc. Professor
University of Manitoba
July Chaneton
Facultad de Ciencias Sociales
Universidad de Buenos Aires
Amy L. Brandzel
Assistant Professor of American Studies and Women Studies
University of New Mexico
Daisy Deomampo
Assistant Professor
Dept. of Sociology & Anthropology
Fordham University
Patrick R. Grzanka
Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology
University of Tennessee
Aren Aizura
Assistant Professor of Women and Gender Studies
Arizona State University
Sara Warner, Ph.D.
Associate Professor
Department of Performing and Media Arts
Cornell University
Anu (Aradhana) Sharma
Chair and Associate Professor of Anthropology
Wesleyan University
Gregory Mitchell, PhD
Assistant Professor of Women’s, Gender & Sexuality Studies
Williams College
Nayla Vacarezza
Faculty of Social Sciences, Sociology Department
University of Buenos Aires
Katherine Broad, Ph.D.
Department of English
CUNY Graduate Center
Miranda Joseph
Associate Professor and Director of Graduate Studies
Department of Gender & Women’s Studies
University of Arizona
Scott Morgensen
Associate Professor
Department of Gender Studies
Queen’s University
Gabriel Giorgi
Associate Professor
Department of Spanish and Portuguese Languages and Literatures
New York University
Katie King
Professor, Women’s Studies Department & Program
Affiliate, Comparative Literature, American, LGBT, and Performance Studies
Fellow, Maryland Institute for Technology in the Humanities (MITH)
University of Maryland, College Park
Dr Rutvica Andrijasevic
School of Management
University of Leicester
Meryl Altman
Professor of English and Women’s Studies
DePauw University
James-Henry Holland
Asian Studies
Hobart and William Smith Colleges
Suzanne Bergeron
Professor of Women’s Studies and Social Sciences
Director of Women’s and Gender Studies
Book Review Editor, International Feminist Journal of Politics
University of Michigan Dearborn
Kari Lerum, PhD
Associate Professor
School of Interdisciplinary Arts & Sciences
University of Washington, Bothell
Ellen Gruber Garvey, Ph.D.
Professor, Department of English
New Jersey City University
Amanda Swarr
Associate Professor
University of Washington
Yukiko Hanawa
East Asian Studies
New York University
Katrina Karkazis
Senior Research Scholar
Center for Biomedical Ethics
Stanford University
Lucinda Ramberg
Assistant Professor of Anthropology and Feminist, Gender, and Sexuality Studies
Cornell University
Georgiann Davis
Assistant Professor of Sociology
Southern Illinois University Edwardsville
Ian Carter
Associate Professor
California College of the Arts, SF and Oakland
Sally Markowitz
Professor of Philosophy
Willamette University
Heather N. Lukes
Assistant Professor, Critical Theory and Social Justice
Occidental College
Molly K. McGarry
Associate Professor of History
UC Riverside
Hugh Miller, PhD
Assistant Professor
Department of Philosophy
Loyola University Chicago
Frann Michel
Professor of English
WGS, AES, FILM
Willamette University
Cari Carpenter
Associate Professor of English
West Virginia University
Debra Schultz
Department of History
Kingsborough Community College
Caitlin Cahill, PhD
Assistant Professor
Urban Geography & Politics
Social Science & Cultural Studies
Pratt Institute, New York
Dr Emily Grabham
Senior Lecturer
Kent Law School
University of Kent
Dr. Maria CANDEA
Assistant professor, Linguistique française
Sorbonne Nouvelle University, Paris, France
Dr Vincent Pidoux
Senior Lecturer, Institute for Social Sciences
University of Lausanne
John Protevi
Phyllis M Taylor Professor of French Studies
Professor of Philosophy
Louisiana State University
Prof. Francesco Panese
Associate professor of social studies of science and medicine
University of Lausanne (Switzerland)
Marie Helene Bourcier
Faculty Member, Art and Culture
Lille 3 university-France
Nigel Paneth MD MPH
University Distinguished Professor
Departments of Epidemiology & Biostatistics and Pediatrics & Human Development
College of Human Medicine
Michigan State University
Ellen Pollak
Professor Emerita
Department of English
Michigan State University
Davide Morselli
Lecturer / Maītre Assistant
Swiss National Centre of Competence in Research LIVES
Bātiment Géopolis – University of Lausanne (Switzerland)
Alba Brizzi
Institut des sciences sociales
Faculté des sciences sociales et politiques
Université de Lausanne (Switzerland)
Séverine Rey, PhD
Professor (Anthropology)
University of Health Sciences / University of Applied Sciences of Western Switzerland (HES-SO), Lausanne, Switzerland
Sharon Thompson
Independent Scholar
Co-Editor, Powers of Desire
Maxime Cervulle
Associate Professor, University of Paris 8
Vincennes – Saint-Denis
Robbie Duschinsky
Reader in Psychology & Society
Northumbria University
Ellen Hertz
Professeure, Institut d’ethnologie
Université de Neuchâtel (Switzerland)
Sheila Dauer
Adjunct Asst. Prof. at the Graduate Program in International Affairs
The New School for Public Engagement
Jay Arena
Department of Sociology, Anthropology, and Social Work
College of Staten island
Stephanie Pache
Chercheuse invitée / Visiting scholar
IRIS – EHESS (Paris) and
Institut universitaire d’histoire de la médecine et de la santé publique
University of Lausanne (Switzerland)
Sarah Elspeth Patterson
PhD student, CUNY Graduate Center
Tamara Williams Van Horn
Doctoral Candidate, University of Colorado-Boulder
Matthias Lehmann
PhD Candidate
Faculty of Law
Queen’s University Belfast
Hanna Secher Fromell (MSc in Biogeosciences)
Department of Gender Studies
Faculty of Social and Political Sciences
University of Lausanne, Switzerland
Hannah Klaas
PhD student in psychology
University of Lausanne (Switzerland)
Leo Parascondola
Dept of English
William Paterson University
Richard S. Pressman
Professor of English
St. Mary’s University (Texas)
Rustem Ertug Altinay
Doctoral candidate
Department of Performance Studies
New York University
Alexander E. Thornton
MAS candidate, Marine Biodiversity and Conservation (’14)
Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD
Jennifer J. Reed
University of Nevada, Las Vegas
Department of Sociology
Patricia CAILLÉ
Maîtresse de Conférences
Département Information-Communication
Université de Strasbourg (FRANCE)
Simon Dubois
Responsable de recherche
Laboratoire des sciences de l’éducation
Université de Lausanne
Dr. David Frier
Senior Lecturer in Portuguese
School of Modern Languages and Cultures
The University of Leed
Jessica Auerbach
Mailman school of public health (2009)
NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene
Barbara Chubak, MD (Columbia College, Class of 2002)
Montefiore Medical Center
Albert Einstein College of Medicine
Elizabeth Anne Wood, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Sociology
Nassau Community College
Cara Herbitter
Clinical Psychology Doctoral Student
UMass Boston
Simone Kolysh, MPH, M.Phil
The CUNY Graduate Center
Christoph Hanssmann (MPH)
Sociology Doctoral Student, UCSF
Jill Leigh
Wellbeing Adviser, Student Support and Wellbeing
University of Kent
Claire Bond Potter
Professor of History
The New School for Public Engagement
Nancy Barnes
Humanities, School for Undergraduate Studies
The New School for Public Engagement
Tom Boellstorff
Professor of Anthropology, University of California, Irvine
former Editor-in-Chief, American Anthropologist
Debbora Battaglia
Professor of Anthropology and Five College Fortieth Anniversary Professor
Mt. Holyoke College
Leora Auslander
Professor, Chair, Collegiate Affairs Committee
History Department
Center for the Study of Gender and Sexuality
Center for Jewish Studies
University of Chicago
Bettina Bock von Wülfingen
Associate Professor, Institute for Cultural History and Theory
Cluster of Excellence Image Knowledge Gestaltung
Humboldt Universität zu Berlin
Lila G. Braine
Professor Emerita (Psychology)
Barnard College
Tovah P. Klein, Ph.D.
Director, Barnard College Center for Toddler Development
Associate Professor, Psychology
Barnard College
Tina Campt
Professor of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies
Director of the Africana Studies Program
Barnard College
Katie Glasner
Co-Chair, Senior Associate
Department of Dance
Barnard College
Anupama Rao
Associate Professor, Department of History
Barnard College
Senior Editor, Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa, and the Middle East
Fanny Ambjörnsson, PhD
Associate Professor, Gender Studies
Stockholm University, Sweden
Janne Bromseth, PhD
Associate Professor, Gender Studies
Stockholm University, Sweden
Renita Sörensdotter, PhD
Gender Studies
Stockholm University, Sweden
Ulrika Nilsson, PhD
Associate Professor, Gender Studies
Stockholm University, Sweden
Elin Abrahamsson
PhD student, Gender studies
Stockholm university, Sweden
Maria Margareta Österholm, PhD
Gender studies
Stockholm university, Sweden
Lauren Porsch, MPH
Mailman Class of 2005, Barnard Class of 2001
Meredith Linn, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Urban Studies Program
Barnard College and Columbia University
Sabine Pakora
Master 2 Genre Politique et sexualité
EHESS
Ecole des hautes études en sciences sociales
Paris, France
Rebecca ROGERS
Professor
Université Paris Descartes
Isabel Boni
Sociologist, Docteure EHESS
Research Fellow of Centre Maurice Halbwachs (CNRS/EHESS/ENS)
Paris, France
Prof. Dr. Sigrid Schmitz
Professur Gender Studies
Universität Wien (Austria)
Fakultät für Sozialwissenschaften
Institut für Kultur- und Sozialanthropologie
Katharina Beclin
Ass.-Prof.in Mag.a Dr.
Institut für Strafrecht und Kriminologie
der UNIVERSITÄT WIEN (Austria)
Abteilung für Kriminologie
Hanna Hacker, Prof PhD
Professor of Social and Cultural Development Studies
University of Vienna, Austria, Europa
Department of Development Studies
Gaël POTIN
Political Science
Université Paris 8, France
Dr.Joan Mencher
Emerita Professor
CUNY Graduate Centre and Lehman College of CUNY
Dr. Wolfgang L. Gombócz
Professor of Philosophy (Retired)
University of Graz, Austria
Henry Abelove
Willbur Fisk Osborne Professor of English, Emeritus
Wesleyan University
Jennifer Saul
Head of Department
Department of Philosophy
University of Sheffield
United Kingdom
Dr. Theo van der Meer
Vice-president FWOS (Fonds Wetensschappelijk Onderzoek Seksualiteit,Fund Scientific Research Sexuality)
The Netherlands
Crystal Jackson
John Jay College of Criminal Justice
(She asked me to post on her behalf) Thank you
Aziza Ahmed
Associate Professor of Law
Northeastern University School of Law
Celina Su
Associate Professor of Political Science
City University of New York
Peter Odell Campbell
Department of Communication Studies
Northeastern University
Nadia Guessous
Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow in Women’s and Gender Studies
Rutgers, New Brunswick
J. Kehaulani Kauanui
Associate Professor, Anthropology and American Studies
Wesleyan University
Visiting Lecturer, Cornell University Law School
doctoral candidate, Cornell University Department of Human Development
alumna of Columbia College and Columbia University School of Law
Columbia College (AB 1986) Columbia University School of Law (JD 1989)
Padma Govindan
Doctoral Student, Department of Anthropology
University of California, Irvine
Assistant Clinical Professor of Pediatrics
Columbia University Medical Center
Sine Plambech
Social Anthropologist. PhD-Fellow. ABD. Department of Anthropology. University of Copenhagen. Denmark
Federal University of Minas Gerais
Brazil
Jeff Redding
Associate Professor
Saint Louis University School of Law
Saint Louis, Missouri, USA
Simon Evnine
Associate Professor
University of Miami
Suzanna
Professor of Philosophy
University of Minnesota
Funding models that value faculty for the revenue they bring in rather than the research, teaching, and mentoring that they do is a sure way to destroy what matters about a university–as the shocking dismissal of these two stellar scholars and teachers demonstrates.
Please add my name.
Julie R. Klein
Associate Professor of Philosophy, Villanova University
Elaine Swan
Senior Lecturer, School of Communication, University of Technology, Sydney.
Instituto de Medicina Social
Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro
Maddie Breeze
Sociology PhD
Edinburgh University
Mario Pecheny
Professor of Sociology of Health
University of Buenos Aires
Shilpa Phadke, Assistant Professor, School of Media and Cultural Studies, Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai
Carole Vance’s work has been central to the development of my own ideas around not just sexuality and pleasure, but also women’s right to public space and the ideas of risk that I was articulated. I feel privileged to have sat in her summer school classrooms.
Sahar Sadjadi, PhD, MD
Assistant Professor
Amherst College
My Ph.D. is from Mailman School of Public Health, Sociomedical Sciences (1997). Dr. Vance was a first rate teacher and dissertation advisor.
Marian Reiff
Sr. Research Investigator
Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, PA
Sheryl McCurdy
Associate Professor
Division of Health Promotion and Behavioral Sciences
University of Texas School of Public Health
Houston Health Science Center
Khary Polk
Assistant Professor of Black Studies & Sexuality, Women’s and Gender Studies
Amherst College
Margaret R. Hunt
Professor of History
Uppsala University
Uppsala, Sweden
Tiphaine Besnard
Sociology PhD
Paris 8 CSU Cnrs
Deborah Gewertz
G. Henry Whitcomb Professor of Anthropology
Amherst College
Amherst MA
Anthropology and East Asian Studies,
Smith College
Northampton, MA
Clinical Assistant Professor
Gallatin School of Individualized Study
NYU
Michele Aina Barale
Thalheimer Professor of English and of Sexuality, Women’s, and Gender Studies
Amherst College
Leyla Keough
Visiting Asst. Professor of Anthropology
Hampshire Collegw
Christopher Dole
Chair, Department of Anthropology & Sociology
Amherst College
Matthew J. Hill
Associate Director, Center for Heritage & Society
UMass Amherst
Eunmi Mun
Assistant Professor of Sociology
Amherst College
Elizabeth L. Krause
Professor
University of Massachusetts Amherst
Chad Heap
Associate Professor of American Studies
George Washington University
Lynn Festa
Associate Professor
Rutgers University
Senior Research Officer
University of Essex
Laura Murray
PhD Candidate
Columbia University
Department of Anthropology, UMass Amherst
Department of Comparative Human Development, University of Chicago
PhD candidate
Department of Comparative Literature
University of Michigan
Cookie Woolner
History and Women’s Studies PhD candidate
University of Michigan
MicKenzie Fasteland
PhD Candidate
Department of English and Women’s Studies
University of Michigan
PhD Candidate
Department of Comparative Literature
The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
Luca Greco
Associate Professor
Deparment of Language Sciences
Paris III University
Michael Connors Jackman, PhD
Lecturer
Department of Anthropology
York University
School of Social Work
University of Michigan
Josh Morrison
Screen Arts & Cultures
University of Michigan
PhD Candidate
Department of Anthropology
University of Michigan
Evren Savcı
Assistant Professor
Department of Women and Gender Studies
San Francisco State University
OISHIK SIRCAR
Teaching Fellow and Doctoral Candidate
Institute for International Law and the Humanities
Melbourne Law School, The University of Melbourne
Stephen Molldrem
Doctoral Student, Department of American Culture
The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
Vincent Palliez
PhD candidate
Faculty of Law, University of Liège, Belgium
Faculty of Political Science, University of Antwerp, Belgium
What disgraceful treatment of Carole Vance. How is such a thing possible?
W. H. Auden Distinguished University Professor of the History and Theory of Sexuality
Professor of English, Women’s Studies, Comparative Literature
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
PhD Student, Department of Comparative Literature
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
This news is utterly shocking and the decision uncalled for.
History / German ~ University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
Robert Paynter
Professor of Anthropology
University of Massachusetts Amherst
Spectrum Center
School of Information
University of Michigan
Disturbing and all too consistent with current economic reorganizations. Has anyone calculated Vance’s financial contributions to Columbia over 27 years through grants and the modeled value of supervision, instruction etc (using the University’s own monetization schemes)? I expect it exceeds by far what she has been paid or spent, and would easily support her to and through retirement, and that’s not counting the things that matter more, like knowledge production, scholarly training outcomes, fruitful collaborations, field-founding, discovery, institutional recognition and prestige, etc. Odd whose monetizing gestures count and whose don’t. It wouldn’t be a pleasant exercise but it would be revealing.
Sincere thanks and support to Vance and to her colleagues signing on to the Senior Scholars letter .
Professor of Anthropology Emeritus
Queens College, City University of New York
Greggor Mattson
Assistant Professor of Sociology
Gender, Sexuality and Feminist Studies Institute
Oberlin College
Summer Institute for Sexuality, Culture and Society 1998
University of Amsterdam
Chris Ashford
Professor of Law and Society
Law School, Northumbria University, United Kingdom
I *strongly* support this petition.
Laura Ciolkowski
Associate Director
Institute for Research on Women, Gender, and Sexuality
Adjunct Associate Professor of English & Comparative Literature
Columbia University
I support this petition.
Ryan R. Judkins
Postdoctoral Teaching Fellow
University of Massachusetts – Boston
Ozge Savas
PhD Student, Joint Program in Women’s Studies and Psychology
University of Michigan
Thomas Chen
Lecturer, American Studies
Tufts University
Maja Seselj
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Bryn Mawr College
Scott De Orio
Doctoral Candidate
History and Women’s Studies
University of Michigan
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey
Student of Carole Vance at University of Amsterdam’s Summer Institute on Sexuality, Culture, & Society, 2008.
Oxford-Princeton Global Leaders Postdoctoral Fellow;
Student of Prof. Carole Vance at University of Amsterdam’s Summer Institute on Sexuality, Culture, & Society, 2008.
Executive Director
India HIV/AIDS Alliance
New Delhi
Student of Professor Vance at University of Amsterdam’s Summer Institute on Sexuality, Culture & Society, 2008
Dr. Vance has had an enormous impact on my academic work, for which I am continually grateful.
Student of Professor Vance at University of Amsterdam’s Summer Institute on Sexuality, Culture & Society, 2008
A Visiting Fellow of Prof Vance’s Rockefeller Program in Gender, Sexuality, Health & Human Rights, 1999
Hadley Renkin
Assistant Professor of Gender Studies
Central European University
Budapest, Hungary
Beate Slok-Andersen
Gender Equality Officer, University of Copenhagen,
Student of Carole Vance at University of Amsterdam’s Summer Institute on Sexuality, Culture, & Society, 2008.
Tomomi Yamaguchi
Associate Professor of Anthropology
Department of Sociology and Anthropology
Montana State University
Associate Professor of Cross-Cultural Studies
Kanagawa University
Yokohama, Japan
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Department of Anthropology
Hamilton College
Clinton, NY 13323
PhD Candidate (abd)
University of Michigan
Departments of Women’s Studies and Sociology
Associate Professor
McGill University
Aleza Summit
Mailman School of Public Health alum (MPH, 2012)
Center for Reproductive Health Education in Family Medicine, Montefiore Medical Center
Vanessa Fong
Associate Professor of Anthropology
Amherst College
Roger Noël
Coordinator, Bureau de lutte contre l’homophobie
Ministère de la Justice du Québec
Elif Babül
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Mount Holyoke College
Robert Schwartzwald Professor of English Studies Université de Montréal
Department of Geography, University of Toronto
Add my name. My affiliations are King’s College London and University of St. Andrews.
Please add my name! Trude Bennett, Associate Professor, Department of Maternal and Child Health, UNC Chapel Hill, Gillings School of Global Public Health
MPH Class of 2010
Mailman School of Public Health
Columbia University
Department of Sociomedical Sciences
Dear President Bollinger,
I am writing to ask you to reinstate Dr. Carole Vance’s position at Columbia University. I continue to be forever indebted to her for her intellectual generosity and scholarly expertise on art, visual culture, independent filmmaking, human rights/women’s criminalization, censorship and sexuality studies. Thanks to your generosity of spirit and Carole Vance’s intellectual power and passionate activism on behalf of artists and scholars across the U.S. for decades, I am a tenured professor at the University of Michigan. Please do not let her go from Columbia. She is too valuable a Columbia scholar to too many artists and scholars and students for you to lose her.
Yours sincerely,
Carol Jacobsen
jacobsen@umich.edu
MFA Student, Boston University
I entirely support this petition.
Ragnar Anderson
MPH Class of 2011
Advisee of Carole Vance
Guttmacher Institute
New York City
**
Center for Interdisciplinary Inquiry and Innovation in Sexual and Reproductive Health (Ci3)
University of Chicago
Alex Gil
Digital Scholarship Coordinator
Humanities and History
I support this petition she’s an Amazing Woman
PhD candidate, Columbia University
Doctoral Candidate in History
University of Michigan
The decision to fire these two incredible scholars also sends a very clear message to doctoral students on the job market: Your academic worth is based on the corporate university’s bottom line.
This is not what higher education should be about. If it is, then undergraduate students deserve a refund.
Laurence Piper
Professor of Political Studies
University of the Western Cape
I believe in academic learning, leadership and freedom. Research and learning in higher education needs to be made relevant in the community and such public intellectuals are key to this process.
Professor, English Department
Hofstra University
Assistant Professor, Literary Studies
The New School
I have always thought of Carole Vance as among Columbia’s most distinguished faculty and as representing the most admirable side of the University. Her contributions are enormous and unmatched; I find it inconceivable that she should be required to raise grant money for her truly revolutionary work and scholarship.
ASA-NSF Postdoctoral Fellow
Department of Sociology
University of Wisconsin-Madison
I support this petition.
Connie Samaras
Professor, Department of Art
University of California, Irvine
I support this petition.
Anne Walsh
Associate Professor, Department of Art Practice
University of California, Berkeley
Dr John Di Stefano
Associate Professor
University of Sydney
Kavita Philip
Associate Professor, History
University of California, Irvine
Carole Vance’s influence has been widely felt in multiple fields, including public health, sociology, art, gender studies, and history. She is much respected as an excellent professor and an important thinker. In many ways, she is the standard. It’s a mystery why Columbia is so determined to damage its reputation.
Simon Leung
Megan Boler
Professor
OISE/University of Toronto
Monica Majoli
Associate Professor
Department of Art
UC Irvine
Joel Michael Reynolds
PhD Candidate
Arts & Sciences Graduate Fellow
Bernard Forgues
Professor, Director of the Ph.D. Program
EMLYON Business School (France)
Professor of Sociology
University of Sussex, UK
I was shocked and saddened to learn about the firing of Carol Vance. I urge Columbia University to reverse their decision and to review their guidelines for according merit and employment status to untenured faculty!
Srirupa Prasad
Assistant Professor, Women’s and Gender Studies
University of Missouri-Columbia
Professor Emerita
Department of Art
University of California, Irvine
Lisa R. Rubin
Associate Professor, Psychology
New School for Social Research.
Carol Vance an immensely influential and inspiring scholar. This would be a great loss for Columbia and its students. I sincerely hope the decision is reconsidered.
Columbia needs to offer these two brillant educators tenor, not dismiss them.
Tenure
Ken MacLeish
Assistant Professor
Center for Medicine, Health and Society and Department of Anthropology
Vanderbilt University
Catherine Hodes, LCSW
Shocking. Columbia, and other universities, in danger of becoming wastelands.
Matias Viegener
Professor, Critical Studies
California Institute of Arts
I’ve taught Carol Vance’s work in graduate seminars. It’s absurd that academics like Vance and Kim Hopper are in these precarious positions at what we consider major research universities. I’m a Columbia grad & I expect better of my alma mater.
Sara M. Bergstresser, PhD MPH
Columbia has made a very poor decision, and I am very disappointed.
This is terrible. Please tell me this story is not true. Reinstate Dr. Carole Vance!
Ph.D student, sociology
Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales, Paris, France
Associate Professor of Gender and Sexuality Studies, Anthropology, and Comparative Literature
University of California at Irvine
Over the past three decades, Dr. Carole Vance’s research and teaching have advanced novel methods and profoundly deepened the fields of gender and sexuality studies, public health, and medical anthropology. Columbia University should apologize to her for such a colossal act of disrespect and reinstate her immediately.
Associate Clinical Professor of Psychiatry
Pritzker School of Medicine
University of Chicago
Associate Professor of Japanese History and Literature
Department of East Asian Languages and Cultures
Columbia University
Dr Jonathan Kemp
Associate Lecturer in Creative Writing
Birkbeck College,
University of London
Eric Fassin Professor of Sociology
Department of Political Science and Gender Studies Center,
Paris 8 Vincennes-Saint-Denis University
Nacira Guénif
Full Professor, Université Paris 8, France
Prof. Sabine Hark
Chair in Gender Studies at Technische Universitaet Berlin
Laura Affolter
PhD candidate, Institute of Social Anthropology, University of Berne
Prof. Dr. Julia Eckert
Institute for Social Anthropology
University Bern
Todd Sekular, MPH (CU 2007)
Doctoral candidate, Institut für Europäische Ethnologie, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
Cornelia Möser, Ph.D.
Research Associate, Centre de Recherches Sociologiques et Politiques de Paris
Nanna Heidenreich, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor, Media Studies, University of the Arts in Braunschweig
Damon Young, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor, Screen Arts and Cultures, University of Michigan
Gabriele Dietz, Ph.D.
Guest Professor, Dartmouth College
Dorothea Dornhof, Ph.D.
Lecturer, Institut für Kulturwissenschaft, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
Chris Tedjasukmana, Ph.D.
Research Associate, Institut für Theaterwissenschaft, Freie Universität, Berlin
Beate Binder, Ph.D.
Professor
Institut für Europäische Ethnologie, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
Mathias Danbolt, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor, Department of Arts and Cultural Studies
University of Copenhagen
Katrina Köppert, M.A.
Doctoral Candidate, Lehrstuhl für Mediengeschichte
Universität Siegen
Ulrike Klöppel, Ph.D.
Research Associate, Humboldt Universtität zu Berlin
Pat Treusch
Doctoral Candidate, TU Berlin; Germany and Tema Genus, Linköping University, Sweden
Jan Hutta, Ph.D.
Research Associate, Lehrstuhl für Kulturgeographie, University of Bayreuth
Marietta Kesting
Doctoral candidate, Research associate
Exzellenzcluster Bild Wissen Gestaltung, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
Friedrich von Bose
Research Associate, Doctoral Candidate
Institut für Europäische Ethnologie, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
Dagmar Fink
Vienna Austria, Board Member, Association of Feminist Scholars in Austria
Boel Berner
Professor em
Department of Thematic Studies
Linköping university, Sweden
Laura Kay
Ann Whitney Olin Professor
Dept. of Physics and Astronomy
Barnard College
Dr. Doris Allhutter
Elise Richter Senior-Postdoc
Austrian Academy of Sciences, Institute of Technology Assessment
Popho Eun Sil Bark-Yi, Ph.D.
Research Fellow, Hanshin Academy
Hanshin University, South Korea
Comment: I, as one of scholars who deeply appreciates what Carole Vance has influenced on feminism and politics of sexuality, was in shock to hear such a news.
Lynne Segal. They should both e reinstated at once, however I can’t actually see how to sign the petition!
Miriam Jones
Associate Professor of English Literature
University of New Brunswick, Saint John
Aditi Chaturvedi
Ph.D. Student, Department of Philosophy
University of Pennsylvania
Danae DiRocco, MPH
PhD Student, Department of Anthropology, University of Michigan
Shocking. Carole Vance is an important public intellectual, a brilliant scholar and still finds the time to be an amazing professor and generous mentor. Mailman is making a tremendous mistake that will have long-term implications for the institution’s reputation.
Elisabeth L. Engebretsen, PhD
International Institute for Asian Studies, Leiden, the Netherlands.
Debolina Dutta,
PhD Fellow,
Melbourne Law School,
University of Melbourne
Prof. Vivek (Vik) Kanwar
Associate Professor of Law, Jindal Global Law School (JGLS)
Executive Director, Centre on Public Law and Jurisprudence (CPLJ)
O.P. Jindal Global University
Sonipat, Haryana, 131 001
NCR of Delhi, India
PhD candidate
University College London, UK
Pingback: Injustice at Columbia: Power and public health | a paper bird
Carol Vance’s contribution to Gender and Sexuality Studies in India is invaluable. Columbia University’s decision is shameful. We demand that they revoke the order of termination.
Assistant Professor, Sociology and Social Anthropology
Department of Humanities and Social Sciences
Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
Hikari Hori
Assistant Professor
Dept. of East Asian Languages and Cultures
Columbia University
Richard Fung
Associate Professor, Faculty of Art
OCAD University
Toronto, Canada
The ability to study public health and social justice issues with professors like Kim Hopper and Carole Vance is the reason that people choose Mailman over other schools of public health. Letting them go is Columbia’s shameful loss.
Linda Briskin, Phd
Professor Emeritus, Social Science Department/School of Gender, Sexuality and Women’s Studies
York University, Toronto, Canada
Surabhi Shukla, Senior Research Associate, Jindal Global Law School, O.P.Jindal Global University.
Professor, Social Science
York University
Toronto, Canada
Gloria Careaga
Faculty of Psychology
National University of Mexico. UNAM
Tamara Adrian
Faculty of Law
Universidad Central de Venezuela UCV
Universidad Católica Andrés Bello UCAB
Universidad Metropolitana UNIMET
Caracas, Venezuela
Department of History and School of Gender, Sexuality, and Women’s Studies
York University
Toronto, Canada
Dr.
Social Psychology, University of Bern, Switzerland
Associate Professor, Department of History
University of New Mexico
Postdoctoral Fellow, Behavioral Science Training in Drug Abuse Research Program
National Development and Research Institutes
New York City
Kimberly Gauderman
Associate Professor, Department of History
University of New Mexico
Laura Sjoberg
Associate Professor
Political Science, University of Florida
Homebase Editor, International Feminist Journal of Politics
University of Melbourne
I hardly ever sign petitions, but this time I do because I feel that this case is an ominous sign of a new trend in adademics: putting money-earning before high quality research and teaching.
Renee Petropoulos
Professor Graduate Studies
Otis College of Art and Design
Eduardo Mattio
Profesor Asistente
Facultad de Filosofía y Humanidades
Universidad Nacional de Córdoba, Argentina
.
Bergen Cooper
Mailman School of Public Health, MPH ’13
Policy Research Associate, Center for Health and Gender Equity
Consultant, World Health Organization
Wendy Coburn
Associate Professor
Faculty of Art, OCAD University
Toronto, Canada
Wei Wei
Associate Professor
School of Social Development
East China Normal University
Shanghai, China
I have had the honor to work with Professor Vance during my last two semesters at Columbia. Without her committed support, I would not have been able to conduct my current thesis research. Moreover, as an aspiring practitioner in the field of human rights and gender equality, it cannot be understated that Professor’s Vance’s contributions to these fields, and to my and many students’ personal development, are immeasurable. Columbia would not be the same without her intellectually formidable presence.
Sidra Zaidi
M.A. Candidate, Human Rights Studies, Columbia University
Shocking news and this decision certainly casts a shadow on Columbia’s administration. Vance is an influential scholar in many disciplines
Carol Vance is one of the great leaders among feminist academics. Her writing and her constant political engagement pressed feminist thinking and action forward in innumerable ways. Her sometimes-controversial insistence on integrating sexuality into sex equality debates, as well as her infinitely sophisticated thinking about transnational equality, have made her one of my role models for a long time. She should be venerated, not fired.
Darren Rosenblum, Professor Pace Law School
Postdoctoral Associate-in-Law & Fellow, Yale Law School
Ariela J. Gross
John B. & Alice R. Sharp Professor of Law and History, University of Southern California
Professor of Law, University of La Verne College of Law
Mary L. Dudziak
Asa Griggs Candler Professor of Law
Emory University School of Law
Atlanta, Georgia, USA
Dara E. Purvis
Assistant Professor of Law
Penn State University Dickinson School of Law
Faculty of Law
University of Manitoba
Winnipeg, MB
Canada
Sue Lloyd, Associate Professor, Visual Studies, Daniels Faculty of Architecture, Landscape and Design, University of Toronto
Allyson M. Lunny
Assistant Professor
Law and Society program
Graduate program in Socio-Legal Studies
York University
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Kunal Ambasta
Assistant Professor
National Law School of India University
Bangalore, India
College Fellow
Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies
Harvard University
Kaining Zhang, Professor, Director Yunnan Health and Development Research Association (YHDRA), Yunnan, China.
Associate Professor, Department of Sociology, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China
Saint Louis University School of Law
Lisa Bloom
Research Scholar, Center for the Study of Women
UCLA
Naomi Braine
Associate Professor
Sociology Dept
Brooklyn College
City University of NY
Oliver Phillips, PhD.
Reader,
School of Law,
University of Westminster.
Institute of Sexuality and Gender,
Renmin University of China, Bei Jing
Institute of Medical Humanities,
Peking University,
Beijing, China
Professor, Director,
Institute of Sexuality and Gender,
Renmin University of China, Bei Jing
I was shocked to hear about this. Carol Vance has made major contributions to sexualities studies and public health
Wang Yingyi
MPhil student
The University of Hong Kong
Reader in Global Sexual Health
University College London, UK
Assistant Professor, Depart. of Social Work, Bei Jing Science and Techology University, China
Sonya Lee
Architect, Columbia University (M.Arch, 2004)
Wenqing Kang
Associate Professor
History Department
Cleveland State University
J. Stephen Clark
Professor of Law
Albany Law School
Professor Paul Hunt,
University of Essex
UK
paulhunt28@yahoo.co.uk
Associate Professor, Bei Jing Normal University, China
I support the petition.
Jerry Yung-Ching Chang
PhD Student
Program in Comparative Literature and Literary Theory
The University of Pennsylvania
Amy Schrager Lang
Professor of English & Humanities
Syracuse University
Julie Abraham, Professor, Sarah Lawrence College
Josephine HO, Chair Professor, National Central University, Taiwan
Jun Wang
Independant researcher, consultant on LGBTQ & HIV/AIDS, China
Professor, Department of Public Health, William Paterson University of N.J.
Affiliated faculty, Women’s and Gender Studies Department, William Paterson University of N.J.
Past President, Society for the Scientific Study of Sexuality
We need to stand up to make sure we can do good quality research and ensure knowledge is shared and used by all who can benefit from it
Universities are for mentoring the future generations. Knowledge is power but without excellent educators and mentors there is no success. Dr. Vance is the ultimate professor, and has brought more students to Columbia BECAUSE of her widespread research, writing and mentoring.
Konstance McCaffree, PhD
Retired Professor Widener University
Past President Society for the Scientific Study of Sexuality
President – Elect of the American Association of Sexuality Educators, Counselors and Therapists
Postdoctoral Fellow, Center for Place, Culture, and Politics, CUNY Graduate Center
Margaret Nichols, Ph.D. President, Institute for Personal Growth, New Jersey, Sex Therapist/Teacher.
Carole Vance’s work has been seminal in my field. This would be a great loss to our field, I urge you to reverse the decision
PhD Candidate, University of Southern California
Silke Heumann, Assistant Professor, International Institute of Social Studies, Erasmus University Rotterdam
Professor of International Law and Human Rights, Bard College
Women’s and Gender Studies , Rutgers University
Cynthia Graham, Department of Psychology, University of Southampton
Outrageous! This is the result of the corporatization of academia. Unless we all stand up…!
Katherine Korth
MA Candidate
Anthropology
Wayne State University
Fanis Missirlis, CINVESTAV-IPN, Mexico City.
Shame on the Columbian Ostriches.
Katherine Tamminen, PhD
Faculty of Kinesiology and Physical Education
University of Toronto
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Research Fellow, Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex, UK.
Carole Vance has inspired generations of activists and academics around the world. Without reducing the complex history of the Queer movement in India, it must be said that the influence of her thought and her engagements have been tangible and very significant. the question of value of a person and her/his work being reduced to budgetary calculations is grotesque and myopic.
James S. Ferraro, Ph.D.
Director of Undergraduate Studies in Physiology
Dept. of Physiology
School of Medicine
Southern Illinois University
Carbondale, IL 62901
I wholeheartedly support this petition. I am stunned at this news; Columbia needs to reconsider immediately!
Christina Zampas
Amnesty International, International Secretariat
Sabrina Buckwalter
Arts and Sciences
Columbia University
Alison Cool
Mellon Sawyer Postdoctoral Fellow
Department of Anthropology
New York University
Laura Ferguson
Assistant Professor
Program on Global Health and Human Rights
University of Southern California
I almost could not believe my eyes when I read of Columbia University’s demeaning policy towards Carol Vance, a scholar of uncontested international fame and a wonderful and inspiring colleague at that – if qualifications like these no longer matter at Columbia, I wonder why it keeps calling itself University
This news is appalling. Vance has been a key reference for gender studies, feminism and sexuality in Latin America.
Es un trato inaceptable para toda persona, mayor aún es inaceptable hablando de una académica de vanguardia cuyo aporte ha sido incluso formativo para quienes nos iniciamos en el feminismo académico.
Professor, Master’s Program in Women’s Studies, Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana, Mexico City, Research Area of Women, Identity and Power.
…
Professor,Research Area of Women,Identity and Power & MA in Women’sStudies,Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana,MexicoCity
Laura E. Jones
Senior Researcher, Theoretical Ecology
Cornell University
Ithaca, New York
Lucía Melgar, Ph.D.
Professor in the Political Sciences Dept.
ITAM
Mexico CIty
Jue Ren, Ph.D.
Gender Studies,
The Chinese University of Hong Kong
MONICA JASIS, MD. MPH, Ph.D. cand,
Research Director
Centro Mujeres A.C., La Paz, Mexico
Stefan Lucke
PhD Student, California Institute for Integral Studies (CIIS)
Nathaniel C. Oliver
Adjunct Instructor of English, Northwest-Shoals Community College
Reinstate!
Pablo Jasis, Ph.D, California State University, Fullerton
Center for AIDS Prevention Studies
University of California, San Francisco
Andrew Park
International Program Director, Williams Institute
UCLA School of Law, Los Angeles, California
Aaron H Devor, Ph.D.
Founder and Academic Director, The Transgender Archives
Professor, Sociology Department
University of Victoria
Victoria, BC, Canada
Stephanie Farrior
Professor of Law and Director,
Center for Applied Human Rights
Vermont Law School
Professor, Faculty of Kinesiology and Physical Education, University of Toronto, Toronto ON Canada
PhD Candidate, Department of Anthropology, University of Michigan
Professor
CUNY School of Public Health / Brooklyn College
Joshua Gamson
Professor, University of San Francisco
Prabha Kotiswaran, Dickson Poon School of Law, King’s College London
I am retired from teaching High School English, and I am shocked! Not only should Columbia re-instate Dr. Vance, but she should be given long overdue tenure! My respect for Columbia U. is gone! How crass to value money beyond scholastic excellence! This is what’s wrong in our Universities today, and why I applaud investigative reporting in The Nation.
Agnieszka Koscianska
assistant professor, vice-director, Department of Ethnology and Cultural Anthropology, University of Warsaw, Poland
Dr. Vance greatly inspired the development of gender and sexuality studies in Central Europe.
Pingback: Anthropology News
Leigh Southey
PhD candidate
Dept of Anthropology, University of Johannesburg
Columbia University Club of Chicago (SIPA)
Senior Editor, Business, Economics, and Finance
ABC-CLIO | Praeger | Greenwood
Santa Barbara, CA
Debra J. Pelto, MPH, PhD
Postdoctoral Fellow, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
The financialization of the university impoverishes scholarship.
Amos Oyedokun (PhD)
Department of Demography and Social Statistics, Obafemi Awolowo University, Nigeria.
I met Carol in Amsterdam sometimes in 2008 at a summer school. A person like Carol or any other person should not be treated this way.